Torrey, Al-Asma'i's Fuḥūlut aš-Šuʻarā”.
at some length the work before us, the set
of al-Aṣma'ī,
which he had been able to use while the manuscript was still in Landberg's possession. To his treatment of the subject the reader is accordingly referred. Again, Brockelmann in the Nöldeke-Fest- 5 schrift, I, 109-125, has published a conspectus of one of the
طبقات الشعراء carliest and most important of the fuhila books the
of Muhammad ibn Sallam al-Jumaḥī († 231), making use of all the surviving fragments of the work which he was able to collect. This is a systematic treatise on the ranking of the poets, and there- 10 fore altogether different from the compilation of Abu Hatim, as will presently appear. Finally, we are promised a complete edition of this treatise of al-Jumaḥī in the near future, by Professor Hell of Munich, who has found a manuscript containing it in the Khedivial Library in Cairo; see his announcement in the ZDMG. 64, p. 659, note.
15
As has just been said, the remarks on the poets made by al-Asma'ī, and collected by Abū Пlātim as-Sijistānī under the title Kitāb Fuḥūlat aš-Su'arā', do not constitute anything like a syste- matic compilation. What we have is simply a catena of scattered sayings, of very uneven value, inade on many different occasions, 20 and thrown together without any plan of arrangement. Some of the judgments were given in answer to questions, while others (and these constitute the great majority) were the merest obiter dicta. The opinion expressed is in many cases confined to this one point, the fitness of the poet to bear the title fahl, that is, "thorough- 25 bred male" (especially male camel), or "stallion", a truly Arabian way of picturing the embodiment of pure native blood, masculine force, and high spirit. The holder of this rank must have been, first of all, a poet of very noteworthy achievements; thus it is said of al-Huwaidira, for example: "If he had produced five qasidas so like the one which we have, he would have been a fahl". But he must also have been a true representative of the genuine Arab stock at its best, embodying the qualities which were most characte- ristic of the free and vigorous life of the native clans, battling for their precarious existence on the edge of the desert. As Gold- 35 ziher remarks (loc. cit., p. 135): "Nicht die dichterische Kraft allein macht den Menschen dieser Benennung würdig; diese bezieht sich vielmehr auch auf die Eigenschaften des ritterlichen Charakters”. It is easy to see why the poets of the Islamic time were not easily given the title which seemed to belong by especial right to the 40 primitive period and the Bedawī nobility. Al-Asma'i's estimates, both as to the fuḥūla quality and also on other matters concerning the old poets, while always interesting are frequently not convin- cing. Some are evidently the fruit of long deliberation; others are so carelessly made that we may suspect that al-Asma'ī himself 45 would have modified or even retracted them a few days later, when he was in another mood. One of the incidents narrated near
ص ٤٠