derds anything which is negative to Islam or to the prophet must be authentic. Anything which is favorable must be ex- amined very criticlly. If you look at Lammens, a page of Lammens looks like a normal page of scholaship, with heavy footnotes, references to sources, etc.. But if you look at it more cgosely, the purpose is clearly polemical, just as polem- ical, just as polemical as the earlier medieval writers whose purpose quite frankly was to refute Islam. This was his pur- pose. He was very sympathetic to the Umayyads. Why was he sympathetic to the Umayyads, as were many other orien- talists ? I think that many modern historiens, first Western then also Arab, have thought that the Arab Islamic historio- graphic tradition is unfair to the Umayyads. Most of the Ar- abic histrical texts which we have were written after the fall of the Umayyads, under the Abbasids, and we would not ex- pect historians under the Soviet Union would deal justly with the Czars of Russia. After a revolution, a ttitudes change. What scholars have done is try and go beyond the baised point of view of the Abbaid historians, that is to say his- torians of the Abbasid period, and to reconstruct the Umayy- ad century. Scholars have done that and have argued that af- ter all the Umayyads were not so bad, and some of them like Mu'awiya and Abdul Malik really had qualities of states- manship. This is what I call scholarly work. Lammens` posi- tion was much simpler. If the Muslim tradition was against the Umayyad, the Umayyads were good.
I don`t think there are many nowadays, except some atheist Soviet scholars, Who wtier polemical tracks against Islam from an ideological point of view. Lammens was writing as
- 1.V-
ص ٦٠٧