الإستشراق والإتجاهات الفكرية في التاريخ الإسلامي - مطبقاني — الصفحة ٦٠٨

a catholic missionary. These people write as Marxist mis- sionaries. So we find people like Klimovitch who argues that Muhammad never existed, that there was no such person. He didn't say that Muhammad was not a prophet, but that Mu- hammad never existed. Obviosly this is not a serious scholar- ly position, but it served his polemical purpose. They do not often do that kind of thing nowadays, but in the 1920's and 1930's, when the revolution was still hot, so to speak, there was a lot of anti - Islamic, and generally anti - religious, po- lemical literature, thinly disguised as scholarship . But now- adays anti-Islamic polmeic of a religious type si rare, though we still find it emanating from some Marxists and similar cources. - The scholar does not try to prove anything until he has ex- amined the evidence, formulated his own hypotheses, and then made his own hudgement . If he has the good fortune to live in a free society, he can publish his results subject only to his own scholarly conscience. The essence of this is to be honest, to say what evidence you are using, and how you in- terpret it. What is not honest is to use part of the evience and hidw the rest, to pick and choose what suits you, and dis- regard what does not. That may be good polemic, persuasove advocacy, or effective propaganda. It is not scholarship. - 1.1-
ص ٦٠٨

النص مستخرج آليًّا من صور الكتاب، وقد يقع فيه خطأ.