documintation. The footnote says, "it is not just me that is saying this, I have evidence for it. This is the evidence and you may either agree or disagree, this is your right". But wuen you write a popular general book, you don't put foot- notes, because the general reader would not understand them That little book The Arabs in History was one of a series of general books, and it was the rule of the series to have no footnotes. It was intented for the gneral readers, and most general readers would be simply mystified by a footnote that says "see Tabari, VI, p. 290". In a book of that kind, a scholar or a specialist, if he reads it, will recognize the sources while the non-specialist wouldn`t understand them. In scholsroy books, yes, of course, there must be full documentation show- ing the evidence and arguing the case. What I was refrring to in the passage to which you allude is some writers who car- ried on the religious polemics of earlier times. I told you be- fore that we must make a clear distinction between polemic and scholarship. There are some who carried on from earlier times this polemical attitude -- for example, Lammens. Lam- mens was a capable scholar, and did some important work, but he had a very polemic purpose, which was anti-Islamic . He had a real hostility to Islam. There is no doubt that he was not looking at Islam in an objective or natural way. As a scholar there should be no difference beteween a Muslim and non - Muslim looking at Islam in history. He was not doing that. He was looking at it as a competing, rival religion. And you can see this in his method; For example, any good schol- ar will look critically at evidence, and examine evidence ask- ing "is it authentic ? is it truthful ?" Lammens had two stan-
- 7.7 -
ص ٦٠٦