الإستشراق والإتجاهات الفكرية في التاريخ الإسلامي - مطبقاني — الصفحة ٥٩٣

The final choice must of course rest with you and your teachers, but I would urge you to consider ways to widen your topic, and to give it suf- ficient substance to justify a full length dissertation. Regarding your request for a meeting, there are still some questions which need to be answered before I can decide what to do. My time is in every sense limited, and I must husband it carefully. To put it bluntly, my basic question is whether your approach to this is scholarly or polemical. If is scholarly that is to say, if you will approach and examine the ev- idence with an open mind, follow it wherever it leads, and present your conclusions without fear or prejudice, then I would be delighted to hold such a meeting, which I am sure would be valuable and instructive for both of us. If on the other hand your purpose is polemical that is to say, to select and use evidence in order to support conclusions determined in ad- vance by ideological or institutional authority, then there is really nothing to talk about, and a meeting would be a waste of time for both of us. I therefore repeat my previous suggestion that when you have written a significant portion of your dissertation, you send it to me to read. We shall then both have a much better idea of where we stand. With all good wishes for success in your quest for the truth. Yours sincerely, Bernard Lewis P.S. Have you seen the very interesting articles on the critics of Orien- talism, published by Sadiq al-Azm in Dirasat Arabiyya and by Fuad Zakaria in Fikr? - oar -
ص ٥٩٣

النص مستخرج آليًّا من صور الكتاب، وقد يقع فيه خطأ.