( 26 )
English
190
be refuted by the following: It was authentically proven that no one bewailed the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) as was reported from Qaysibn 'Asim. Even if that has been reported authentically, she confessed in the Hadith that she was young and she repented of that action and admitted her mistake because of the gravity of the ordeal.By this claim, they contradict themselves because how come she slapped her face while she was plotting against him and put the poison for him as they claimed?!
As for the doubts which relate to the family of the Prophet (peace be upon him), the Shiites claim that she hated Ali and did not mention his name. The refutation is as previously mentioned that the relationship between them was good.Scholars have responded to the reported Hadith in this regard, if it is proven to be true, by saying that she did not mention his name because it was not mentioned to her by name because the Prophet sometimes leaned against Al Fadl and sometimes leaned against Ali. In case a disagreement took place between them and that disagreement prevented her from mentioning his name, at
ص ٨٩٥