Understanding the Muslim Malaise
ملا کو جو ہے ہند میں سجدے کی اجازت
ناداں یہ سمجھتا ہے کہ اسلام ہے آزاد
The ambit of religious freedom has not been clearly spelt out in the constitution nor the Constitution tells us that when it speaks of religious freedom what concept of religion it has under discussion. However a Supreme Court verdict involving a Hindu endowment case has this to say:
What constitutes the essential part of a religion is primarily to
be ascertained with reference to the doctrines of that religion itself. 95
But this assurance of the court that the essential part of the religion is to be ascertained by the religion in question or that a religious group has the right to define itself a religion, cannot be taken seriously. For there are many instances when the court has assumed the role of a religious reformer and has directly interfered in Hindu religious matters. For example the change in Hindu Personal Law, allowing a Hindu the right to divorce, banning the Child marriage, making inter-caste marriage legal, abolishing the institution of Devdasi and opening the doors of Hindu temples on Harijans are all indicative of the fact that the concept of religion as defined and practiced by the adherents of the religion has never been acceptable to the judiciary. We have also witnessed a similar attitude of the court in matters of Muslim Personal Law, which at times interpreted the provision in its own way, making it subservient to the uniform civil code -- the directive principles of state policy. The idea of religious freedom as it was understood had no room for practicing Islam in full nor Muslims ever read in it more than an assurance of holding religious gatherings and performing individual and congregational worship. Whatever the reasons may be for having this much of religious freedom in the Constitution the fact was that this concept of religion undermined Islam as an all- embracing religion in the Muslim mind.
60
As for the religions that believed in the separation of Church
ص ٧١