بحوث المؤتمر الجغرافي الإسلامي الاول انجليزي - جامعة الإمام — الصفحة ٢٦١

rounds our lives and within them reasoning has become increasingly dif- ficult. To be rational is not the same as to be reasonable... The spirit of the Enlightenment which glorified reason and freedom, failed to come to terms with the finitude of man... America, the child of 18th. century rationality, has only recently become conscious of the limitations of sci- ence, liberalism and reform through organization". Thus we see that instability characterizes much of "universal" geography today. After a century of tradition and daring innovations-geography is as unsettled as it was about to plunge into modern science at the end of the 19th. century. To put it bluntly, geographers are still groping for a foolproof philosopohy and methodology without the aid of a much needed consensus as to what the goals of the discipline should be. Voices crying for a geography based on relativism, intentionality and meanings are getting loud and clear, but this is by no means a unified view of geographers. Neither is the Marxist dialects nor ecology. Until such time when geographers could be certain about their common goal and role they choose, in the meantime, to go their separate ways. Hence, back to the old saying. that geography is what a geographer does. This is not at all a comforting situation for the crux of the matter seems to lie in the fact that Western geographers define their own ideals, hence the atten- dent values and ethics. So long as they uphold "freedom of the mind" as the highest value (and in this I would say they will unite) they would continue to be insulted by a "call of faith", and there will never be a definite meeting point. With reason alone (by that I mean "reason" as has been defined by Western philosophy and practised in Western culture) and without the aid of an act of faith there can hardly be a unified geography. Even the most humanist existen- tialist in Western geography, I hesitate to say, would continue to be hogged in uncertainty as to where he would direct his willingness and eagerness for "inner communications". Would geography be contented with just "developing a sense of wonder, of awe, at the amazing richness of the human experience through time, (admitting) that the future is (happily) beyond the intellectual or political control of the social scientist" (Buttimer, 1974, 24)? If we might well ask: a sense of wonder, of awe, about whom? Would wondering the richness of human experience be the end in itself? Would it not be directed to the service of some higher ideal? Of God perhapes? Western science will be reluctant to entertain such curiousity because it fears that scientist will be a preacher; preaching is value-loaded and therefore cannot produce objectively-verified knowledge and objectively-verified knowledge is the only true knowledge. - 261 -
ص ٢٦١

النص مستخرج آليًّا من صور الكتاب، وقد يقع فيه خطأ.