past, present and future. An existentially aware geographer is thus less interested in establishing intellectual control over man through precon- ceived analytical models than he is in encountering people and situa- tions in an open, intersubjective manner" (Buttimer, 1974, 24).
Phenomenologists suggest that scientific enquiry should evaluate its adequacy in elucidating the conditions and prospects of life in the everyday world. But existentialism goes further in urging the scientist to help people reach a fuller consciousness of their world through “enlightened choice and decision".
The materials assembled in this section indicate that the geographic notions of man have changed from time to time in accordance with what geographers construed to be the appropriate subject and manner of concern at a particular time. But we could see that through out its evolutionary "progress" from pure description to existentialism it is the positivisit-functionalist paradigm which has marked the most critical period in the history of the discipline. Both in philosophical stance and methodological choice the positivist-functionalist notions of man have been material for controversial polemics. What is most revealing, in my view, is that the reign of positivism in geography has indeed marked the beginning of not-very-positive opinions among geographers regarding the very credibility and authenticity of geography as a source of knowledge. The consequent rise of Behavioralism, Marxist Structuralism, Phenomenology and Existentism is the verdict of its failure. The realization of the inadequacy of functionalist-positivism, however, has been rather gradual. For some geographers its spell is there to stay and no one can claim with cer- tainty that positivist explanation, with all its elegant quantitative equipment, is no longer in vogue, For this reason it may be worthwhile to probe a little deeper into the positivist epistemological foundations in order to understand better the nature of values it articulates in the discipline.
Value and the Epistemological Foundations of Positivist Geography
To unravel the root of positivist legacy in geography, Derek Gregory traces the nature of positivist philosophy in the first chapter of his very recent work (1978, 25-48). He finds out that like other practitioners in social sciences (espe- cially in economy and sociology) geographers sought to uphold the five methodological precepts of Auguste Co mte's (1829) “Cours de philosophie positive". These are: Le re'el, which means that the scientific status of know- ledge has to be guaranteed by the direct experience of an immediate reality. This requires particular conception of causality in which causal relations
- 253 -
ص ٢٥٣