sought to ground both notions in empirical regional studies (Buttimer, 1974, 19).
The fundamental value in the Vidalian tradition was harmony between man and his milieu. However, in articulating the importance of cultural and social characteristics of groups, opinions were divided among Vidalian geographers as to whether an idealistic or materialistic interpretation was appropriate. One attempted to explain landscape in terms of values, ideas, motivations, and attitudes of a culture, while the other based explanation solely on the manifest landscape artifacts of that culture. One was ideational, the other, artifactual, the latter leading directly to a functionalist view. This functionalist view adopted a central tenet of materialism namely, that "since one could know only phenomena, then there is only the phenomenal world" (Buttimer, 1974, 20).
Notwithstanding orientational differences between ideational and functional geographers, most of their early considerations of values in human geography were those inferred from, or imputed to, the humanized landscape. That is to say they endeavoured to explain a certain mode of space use and organization in terms of lifestyles, ideas and attitudes (Sion, 1940; Gourou, 1940, 1964). Thus, both tended in the direction of a functionslist interpretation of values. However, in France, the essential difference lay in the acceptance or denial of the assertion that the spiritual nature of man was significant in geography, and those who advocated man's spiritual uniqueness emphasized the explanatory power of factors such as memory, symbol, hope, habit, and ideals as a consis- tent challenge to explanations based on naturalistic or technological necessity (Febvre, 1925; Vallaux, 1925). In America and Germany, on the other hand, cultural geographers were not concerned with explaining the inner workings of culture or with describing fully patterns of human behaviour, but rather with assessing the technical potential of human communities for using or modifying their habitats (Wagner and Mikesell, 1962, 5).
In these different viewpoints Vidalian geographers showed the variety of ways in which values and meanigs channeled the ecological prerequisites for a viable pattern of living. But, their inferances regarding such meanings were generally based on indirect inquiry, namely, through their landscape expres- sion. It is on this point that Buttimer could not afford much sympathy with the Vidalian geographers. "Why not they" she argued, "endeavor to enter into the life situations of different peoples, and try to reconstruct their ideas and images of their own situations?.... Even if one could document certain associations between cultural attitudes and certain landscape patterns, it was difficult to see
- 249 -
ص ٢٤٩