From whatever is left of our tradition too, we are unable to procure substan- tive work discussing the value premises of our approach. Al-Beiruni, Ibn Khal- dun and Al-Idrisi, among others, remain mere symbolics testifying that once before Muslim geographers had left a permanent mark in the development of the discipline. For, in between their times and ours, stands a long gap of what virtually amounts to silence, inactivity and discontinuity.
What do Geographers Mean by "Values"
J.K. Wright (1947, 12) once claimed that there are probably as many philosophies of the field as there are geographers. And philosophy may be pre- sumed to be integrally related to values. Geographers vary in their philosophies, hence, the values they uphold. For some it may be the sanctify of life, the passion of love, the sacredness of God, the nobility of scholarship and the liberation of mankind. For others they are existing but unidentifiable inner directives. Buttimer, in her "Values in Geography" (1974,9) gives three dis- tinct sets of values characterizing geographers, or for that matter any other academic professional: "there are the personally held or private values which derive from our individual personality, cultural background, and socialization; there is a set of civic or public values which are elicited in the context of social and political life, and finally, the professional values which are operative in our scholarly tasks." This sort of distinction is theoretical and seems only to explain the degree of consistency or conflict in an individual's own behaviour; in real life these sects of values are not, in any sense, separable.
As individuals, then we geographers possess values which are not indepen- dent of the society in which we live and work or with whom we have contact and interact. Since each one of us has our own system of values, each of us too has a philosophy, probably definable as "our own individual view of life and living which provides the beliefs upon which we rest the objectives of our study, the purpose and goal of our professional undertaking. Thus collectively speaking, "it is convenient, therefore, to designate the manifestation of these beliefs in geographical work as the philosophy of geography (Harvey, 1969, 4). It fol- lows, then, that it is not so much the variety of notes struck by the term "values" which is the critical question, but rather the ways in which values have influ- enced and shaped geographers' works, their thoughts, the paradigms of the "what, why, how and for whom" of their work, their ultimate aims as scholars and educationists.
- 244 -
ص ٢٤٤