آثار الامارات العربية المتحدة-غيرملون-انجليزي — الصفحة ١٩٠

THE IRON AGE Concluding remarks There is a wealth of data from southeastern Arabia that is slowly becoming available to permit archaeological dialogue that extends beyond discussions of ceramic typology and the formal analysis of artefacts. Following the publication of the columned hall from Rumailah, it has been possible to attempt to locate that structure within the economic and political milieu of the southeast Arabian Iron Age II period. Here, we have argued that stylistic similarities between architecture and some classes of artefacts should not be used to construct an over arching and generalised model of political economy that owes a great deal to Wittfogelian notions of hydraulic complexity. A detailed and contextual approach to the archaeology of the Muweilah and Rumailah columned halls has highlighted important aspects of shared ideology and ritual, the existence of which certainly poses many questions. However, the evidence from Muweilah suggests that more than one economic strategy was pursued throughout this region during the Iron Age II period. We have documented evidence for Muweilah playing a key role in prestige good exchange that included foreign and locally produced goods. This, however, is only one component of a much larger system of intra- and inter-regional exchange and interaction, the spheres of which undoubtedly extended well beyond the geographical boundaries of southeastern Arabia. Continued research and expeditious publication will further illuminate this regional complexity and serve to further the debate concerning the role of environment, adaptation, trade and imperialism on the configuration of local economies and political structures. 1 2 This is a much revised version of the paper presented in Abu Dhabi in April 2001. Most of these revisions have been prompted by the recent publication of Boucharlat and Lombard (2001) which is of such importance to the subject of the paper. In this paper we refer to this building type as a 'columned hall'. 3 Boucharlat and Lombard (2001: 219) also make reference to a building at Bithna, which they note is 'mais encore très incertain en l'absence de fouilles'. They provisionally ascribe it a similar function to the buildings at Bida Bint Saud, Muweilah and Rumailah on the basis of its size and the recovery of vessels with applique snakes. 5 6 We will adopt Dietler's definition of ritual as 'stylized sequences of action that are performed in such a manner as to be symbolically marked off in some way to distinguish them from daily practice' (Dietler 1999: n. 1). We have discussed in detail elsewhere (Magee n.d. a-c) the evidence for the Iranian influence of this columned hall form. We will not repeat those arguments here, suffice to note that the columned hall from Muweilah has detailed parallels in the Burnt Buildings from Hasanlu and other west Iranian sites. Boucharlat and Lombard (2001) were unaware of the complete form of the Muweilah columned hall when they finished their paper so these parallels did not receive the due emphasis they deserved. We presume that the vessels with appliqué snakes must have formed some part of these rituals. Boucharlat and Lombard (2001: n. 13) note the importance of the snake in ancient Near Eastern symbolism and we look forward to Lombard's article dealing with the relationship of the snake to subterranean water sources. It is necessary to note, however, that within southeastern Arabia evidence for the role of snakes in rituals is most strongly suggested by the excavations at the site of Al Qusais in Dubai. There, a 'serpent temple' was excavated which contained bridge-spouted vessels with appliqué snakes and bronze snakes. 7 Evidence for feasting in the columned hall at Muweilah is further emphasised by the recovery of massive quantities of animal bones in the eastern long rectangular room in Building II. This represented the largest amount of animal bones yet found in any single room throughout the settlement. One example was also found in Building I. Both are illustrated in figure 5. 8 9 That is not to suggest that this was the first use of incense in southeastern Arabia. We note the existence of a cuboid incense burner in 3rd millennium B.C. contexts in Ra's al-Jinz (Cleuziou and Tosi 2000: Pl. 33). 10 We have not seen this publication which is contained within a CD. We presume that the results were not significantly different than those contained in Mouton and Boucharlat 1991. "This is explicitly stated: "The reasons for settling here were apparently different at that time (Islamic period) since almost no shells have been noticed on the surface. The provisional explanation is given by a falaj-like system, a subterranean canal, which is running south towards north, and starting from a point situated about 3 km from Muwailah' (Mouton and Boucharlat 1991: 7). 12 A similar lack of cereal grains was observed after the area was sieved near the columned hall at Rumailah in which smashed storage jars were found. However, this absence seems a more reliable indicator at Muweilah since we undertook extensive sieving and flotation. 13 That the control and redistribution of agricultural products lay at the centre of the political economy of piedmont Iron Age II settlements was suggested by the author in 1999 (Magee 1999: 53-4). 14 In stating this we are cognizant of the important difference between prestige good exchange and prestige good possession or 'diacritic insignia' (Dielter 1999: n. 10). These processes have two different social roles. The former is used to describe the circulation of primitive valuables (Dalton 1965) within a regional poly-centric economy while the latter describes the prestige which is conferred upon those who possess such goods and thus the goods are removed from exchange mechanisms. The archaeological manifestation of this difference is not easy to ascertain but at Muweilah we suggest that objects such as the incense burners, bronze ladles and bridge-spouted vessels played the latter role while the goods described below were part of regional exchange mechanisms. It is important, however, to not absolutely delineate the function of such artefacts into either category; the possession of imported goods (such as iron) would have conferred prestige and authority not only because of the use by elites within regional exchange but also by the initial possession and the ability to control external sources of such goods. 15 More evidence for the use of these stamp seals (impressions on vessels or bullae) would confirm this hypothesis. Lombard has noted the existence of one indistinct bulla impression from Rumailah and suggested that 'Les cachets de Rumailah pourraient donc avoir servi à garantir ou authentifier un scellement de marchandise' (Lombard 1985: 222). 16 The reason why iron has not been found elsewhere during the Iron Age II period is a likely a reflection of the different levels of archaeological preservation. Nearly all excavated Iron Age II settlements were abandoned and one must assume that precious metals like iron would have been taken from the settlement. At Muweilah, the entire settlement is destroyed leaving many prestige artefacts intact. However, the sheer quantity of iron found at Muweilah in comparison to its complete absence elsewhere reinforces our argument that Muweilah was an important link in the distribution of such prestige goods. 190
ص ١٩٠

النص مستخرج آليًّا من صور الكتاب، وقد يقع فيه خطأ.