one comes to recognize it? We would argue that an instrumental value is a function of a given paradigm. In other words, it is the paradigm that drives the engine of any instrumental value. The instrumental value that is attached to an activity or phenomenon is nothing but an extension of a paradigm. Thus, an instrumental value without an inherent ideological value is unthinkable.
A paradigm, to our mind, has its own instrumental value. But that is a different debate. Suffice it to say that a paradigm is what brings the change in the end. A paradigm is what shapes the future. And as we said earlier, it is the paradigm that imparts an instrumental value to a strategy. It is, therefore, obvious that to affect real change, to be able to formulate policies that will be operative in the future, one has to understand the dynamics of paradigm and how a paradigm shift brings about changes to an instrumental value. Needless to say that, in our opinion, neither a paradigm nor any attributed value is to be taken as an end in itself. On the contrary, both paradigm and any assigned instrumental value ought to be considered as means to an end. This is because, over a period of time, as the paradigm changes so does the corresponding instrumental value.
We have briefly delved into the nature of paradigm and its instrumental value because we hold the opinion that any policy or futuristic planning that ignores the role of paradigm in shaping the tangible does so at its own peril. In this context, we may bring in the simile from the Shariah whereby the art of distinction between Usul and Furu' is perfected. Similary, we are trying to argue that a phenomenon should not be judged simply by its instrumental value for such a value is not an independent variable.
Last week, a major paradigm shift was announced in Washington when President Bill Clinton asked for US$100 million to extend the Internet access to American schools, free of charge. This Presidential announcement has tremendous implications for the growth and evolution of education not only in America but throughout the world. It will take globalization of education to unprecedented heights. Tis paradigm shift plans to replace the blackboard with the computer screen. If the Gutenberg Press revolutionized the spread of the printed word and hence the education, this new paradigm shift will result in a comparable situation in the contemporary world and the foreseeable future. For millions of children, learning will acquire a totally new meaning.
It can be understood that technology is at the back of this new paradigm shift. But what is so special about this technological innovation that should engage our attention? The only thing that we may emphasize in the context of present discussion is the defining role of technology, that is to say that is the technology itself setting the agenda rather than the users molding technology to their advantage. The defining technology, therefore, is that technology that imposes itself on our cognitive and behavioral domains and tends to regulate
- 83 -
ص ٨٣