26
greater prominence for the BTWC and the CWC in the region, will be highlighted.
There is no detailed country-specific analysis in this discussion paper, nor does it advocate the accession of certain states before others to either or both of the chemical and biological regimes. Membership of any international treaty—be it related to security issues, trade, the environment, human rights or development-involves a complex assessment of the advantages and disadvantages of membership by the government of each state. It is therefore predominantly a political issue for each state and an issue, which must be confronted by the government of each state.
The final section of this paper will, however, attempt to bring the issues together in a set of concluding points for further exploration and discussion.
THE CWC AND THE BTWC:
SIMILARITIES AND DIFFERENCES IN THE TWO REGIMES
Both treaties complement the 1925 Geneva Protocol and its prohibition on the use in war of chemical and bacteriological weapons. At the heart of the BTWC and the CWC is a determination to exclude completely the possibility of the use of biological and chemical weapons, as outlined in the respective preambular paragraphs of each convention. Unlike the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT), under the BTWC and the CWC the obligations for all states parties are the same and the conventions are principally disarmament treaties with, inter alia, non- proliferation and peaceful cooperation obligations.
the
The BTWC complements the Geneva Protocol by prohibiting the development, production, stockpiling, acquisition or retention of biological and toxin weapons. Although it does not explicitly prohibit their use- because of fears expressed during the 1968-71 period of the negotiations that it might undermine the Geneva Protocol-there is no doubt. among 146 states parties to the BTWC that any use of biological or toxin weapons in armed conflict or for hostile purposes would be a breach of the convention. In contrast the CWC goes further than the BTWC by prohibiting the development, production, acquisition, stockpiling, retention and transfer of chemical weapons to anyone and the use of chemical weapons, as well as military preparations to use chemical weapons.
KTBe_0131622 — ص ٢٦