i
debauchee. Should the debauchee died without being repentance from any revolt he did, he will be sent to the Hell-Fire permenantly as Allah had threatened him and He, Glory Be To Him, should excute His threatening.
Ibn Al-Kaiem's attitude:
Regarding the promise, he thinks that if God promised his servant with anything, such promise will be granted by Him under the provision of the promise and not the worthiness.
Regarding threatening: He thinks that Allah may violate His threatening to the disobedient as He Glory Be To Him is forgiving and generous and He is the All-generosity.
As a result of Solitarians' idea about sending the disobedient permanently to the Hell-Fire, they denid any ideas that opposing theirs, including the advocacy to disobedients and restricted it for repentants only. As a result of their belief in worthiness for punishment and not for reward, they believed also in frustration (i.e. removed of goodnesses by revolts) and expiation (i.e. removal of revolts by goodnesses).
Most of Solitarians see that frustration is on one side only as the revolt depresses all preceeding goodnesses. But Abu Hashiem sees that it has double sides.
The attitude of Ibn Al-Kaiem: He refused the idea of denying the advocacy for disobedients and he proved the eight types of advocacy including that for disobedients. He also refused their ideas in frustration and expiation nothing can frustrate all goodnesses except a postasy and nothing can expiate all revolts except repentance. Regarding Abu Vashiem's opinion, Ibn Al-Kaiem will agree with him if he was intending that goodnesses and revolts are removable. But if he intends to say that there is any revolt, other than apostasy, depresses all goodnesses, or there is any goodness, other than repentance, expiates all revolts, his ideas in such case will be rejected by Ibn Al-kaiem.
4 - To occupy a location between the two categories, where solitarians mean that the disobedient will occupy a location between the two categories both in title and in provision.
Title: Debauchee
Provision: Neither the provision of believer nor unbeliever will be applicable in his life, while in the last day, he will be sent to the Hell-Fire, although his punishment will be less than that of the disbeliever.
170
—
الجزء 01 — ص ١٦٥