Meeting with Professor Lewis, Oct, 21, 1988
Question 1: According to your leters to me, your methodology is not dif- ferent from other schogars in the "Free World". Hoeever do
you think that there are special features which characterize
your methodology, cnd what are these features?
Answer: The bssic methodology is the same. One does not use one meth- odology for my history and one methodology for your his- tory and another methodology fir someone else's history. That would be intellectually dishonest. Somebody who uses one sthnderd for his own culture and religion and uses an- other sthnderd for somebody else's culture and religion is not engaged in scholarship: he is engaged in polemics . I have no objection uo polemic, but polimc is one thing, scholarship is another. and in scholarship as I siad -- there is one basic method which applies to any kind of historical study. There may however be different methodologies for the different types of documintation which are available . Take for example classical Islamic history. There is one type of documentation whiich we who study Islam have at our disposal and which students of other cultures do not have people with names and with details about their back- gtound, education, and careers is enormously available. It means that one can arrive at a degree of understanding of the individual and society which is not possible without this documentation. On the other hand, there is something er lack and that is archives. We have very full archives from
- 7.1 -
ص ٦٠١