الافتخار — الصفحة ٤

Introduction Recent research in the field of Ismā‘ilī studies has clearly demonstrated that certain elements and ideas in the Ismā‘ili system of thought were influenced not only by the beliefs of early extremist Shi'i groups, but also by non-Islamic systems, especially Gnosticism and Neoplatonism. There is, however, in the current scholarship an unresolved debate, which revolves around two issues: What was the original doctrine of the imamate, and what was the earliest cosmogonical and cosmological system? With respect to the first issue, some scholars have contended that the original doctrine preached the return of Muḥammad b. Ismā'il as the Qā'im (the Messiah), and that this article of faith was subsequently modified by the Fāțimids. In the introduction to my Biobibliography, I have argued that to take such an approach gives too much credence to non-Ismā'ili sources and to the Qarmațian position while disregarding the Fatimid position. Abbas Hamdani has also consistently maintained that some scholars have over-emphasized the ideology about the imamate at the expense of realpolitik. The Ismā‘ili movement, like any religio- political movement, contained several trends within the overall structure of certain basic, agreed-upon principles. To view it as homogeneous in all respects to the extent that one would find a fully coherent and uniform doctrine, especially about the identity of the imām during an early phase of the movement when it was operating underground, could lead to inaccurate generalization. The tension between the moderates and the extremists remained latent throughout Ismaili history. From time to time the extremist perspective surfaced and occasionally it come out in the open. The Druzes are a good case in point. With respect to the second issue, some scholars have argued that the earliest Ismā‘ili doctrines were Gnostic and that Neoplatonism, which superseded the previous phase, was introduced later by Abu 'l- Hasan Muḥammad b. Aḥmad al-Nasafi, or al-Nakhshabi (d. 332/943). Others have argued, based on the early dating of the Epistles of the Brethren of Purity (Rasă'il Ikhwān al-Ṣafā'), that Gnostic and 1V
المقدمات — ص ٤

النص مستخرج آليًّا من صور الكتاب، وقد يقع فيه خطأ.