Given Islam's commitment to basic necessities
84
(i.e. rights) of human welfare, failure of a project for which labor (i.e. the borrower) is entirely responsible could be considered a transgression of one's right to security of property (used by the borrower to ensure the loan). Islam traditionally limits return on a loan to a share in the earnings as an incentive for the lender (i.e. capital) to ensure the success of the project undertaken by labor, while labor is to enjoy both a set return (i.e.
85
salary) and a share in the earnings, distributing risk
evenly between capital/lender and labor/borrower.
86
Such concerns for social justice and prosperity
do have a contribution to make, but the lack of financial expertise among religious leaders 87 should lead to caution about rulings against interest. The Qur'an is silent on interest as practiced today, and since the notion of partnership was formulated by scholars and not proclaimed by revelation, it need not be considered a fixed ruling of law."
51
88
الكتاب — ص ٥١