The focus on what is common, rather than what
distinguishes Islam, has led critics to accuse him of wanting to unify all beliefs in a new religion. Is it enough to believe in the oneness of God and to live a morally upright life marked by good works? If it is not necessary to believe in all the prophets, including the prophet of Islam, what does this say about the importance of the Islamic message? Is it simply one message of many that are ultimately relative to the individual believer? The deeper fear is that rejecting a monopoly of salvation would halt the Islamic mission.
His
45
interlocutors,
largely
moderates
themselves," agree that some non-Muslims may merit
salvation on the basis of good works, but that the fate of such a non-Muslim is known only to God and would ultimately involve recognition of the Prophet of Islam. They would also admit the brotherhood of all prophets and thus the brotherhood of all believers, but would insist that this brotherhood includes the Prophet of Islam as the final link in the chain of prophecy.
34
الكتاب — ص ٣٤