All other issues (e.g. the uncreated status of the
Qur'ān, the salvific value of other religions) are matters of opinion and legitimate difference, since they originate not in revelation but in the scholarly heritage.
This is not to look down upon the scholarly heritage or discard it, but to give it a relative status and to recognize the value of its conflicting points of view. The reduction in the status of all but the five pillars of faith is meant to pave the way for an Islamic unity based not on doctrinal uniformity but on recognition of legitimate diversity.20
The Muslim is thus he or she who submits his face to the one God (Q. 2:112). While this is a bald definition of Muslim identity, it envisages credal debate of personal as a legitimate function interpretation (ijtihad) within the available options
(khiyārāt).
16
الكتاب — ص ١٦