INTRODUCTION
15
Sīna on philosophy. "Besides, it (al-Iḥyā') contains a great number of not only weak but also fabricated traditions and allied say- ings, as well as a number of sophistical fallacies and trifles of the Sufis.
"Nevertheless it does also contain the sayings of acknow- ledged, learned Șufi Divines about the actions of hearts, according to Kitāb and Sunnah, as well as other matter concerning tenets of worship and moral behaviour, per- fectly in accordance with Kitāb and Sunnah, which might far more exceed what is dismissible of it.
"It is because of this that there exists such a sharp dif- ferance and variance of opinion about it (the Iḥyā') amongst people" (Majmu'at Fatāwā Ibn Taimiyya, Vol. II, p. 194).
Either Mr. Wensinck is content with Muslims following the path of least resistance, or else he does not relish the prospect of their leaving the beaten track lest it would lead to a revolution, or a renascence of al-Islam. He has voiced this in the following note on p. 254, which will, of course, find an easy concurrence among formal followers of Muslim scholastics :
"Apart from Ibn Hazm and later Hanbalites such as Ibn Taimiya, who stood aloof from the main current of Muslim Thought".
WAS IBN TAIMIYYA AN ANTHROPOMORPHIST?
One of the grievous charges levelled against Ibn Taimiy- ya by the authors of the Encyclopedia of Islam is the following: "An inveterate anthropomorphist, Ibn Taimīya inter- preted literally all the passages in the Kur'an and tradi- tion referring to the Deity. He was so imbued with this belief that, according to Ibn Baṭṭūta, he said one day from the pulpit in the mosque of Damascus: 'God comes down from heaven to earth, just as I am coming down now', and he came down one of the steps of the pulpit staircase" (Shorter Encyclopedia of Islam, article Ibn Taimiya, p. 152, col. 1).
A case of outright calumny, of the whitest lie and the darkest prejudice! Ibn Taimiyya never uttered these words, nor ever did
الكتاب — ص ٥٠٧