The Science of Abrogation is
the Most Important Quranic Science
Precedence of a verse over another is not inferred from the order of verses in the Holy Book because the Qur'an was not arranged according to the order or date of revelation. The date of revelation is known by recourse to authentic, cogent assertion of the Prophet, peace and blessing be upon him. Whenever the date of revelation is unknown, abrogation cannot be claimed, nor considered. That was the second condition, i.e. the abrogator should be dissociated from the abrogated.
The third condition stipulates that the two provisions should not concur in terms of meaning. If they do, it would not be an instance of abrogation. It would rather be an instance of specification of a general provision, restriction of an absolute provision, clarification of a vague provision, and so forth, but not necessarily an act of abrogation. Abrogation applies only when both provisions do not concur at all. However, such lack of convergence in terms of meaning should be conceived only at surface level for, in practice, there can absolutely be no contradiction between two legal provisions because the legislator is one and the same, namely Almighty Allah Most High. Furthermore, not only is the Qur'an perfect, but it is also contradiction-free and its teachings cannot be a subject of contention at all. Contradiction between two legal provisions can therefore only be conceived at surface level. Such superficial contradiction is ascribed to the factor of time for the provision enshrined in a verse revealed at a certain time is valid only at that time. When we move to another era, Allah legislates provisions which suit the requirements of that era. Contradiction leaps to the fore whenever we try to put two provisions within the same temporal framework. If we assign each provision to its own era, there will be no contradiction. But if the two verses do not concur, even if considered in the light of this superficial contradiction, then it is clearly an instance of abrogation as shown in the earlier examples of abrogation.
The fourth condition provides that the abrogator should match the abrogated in terms of theory and practice, which means that both abrogator and abrogated should be of the same status. A text can only be abrogated by a text, and not by rational Ijtihad for pure reason cannot abrogate legislative texts even if there is consensus. Understandably, consensus is achieved in
Y
1
46
ص ٨٣