الإسلام والقرن الحادي والعشرون أبحاث ووقائع - المجلس الأعلى — الصفحة ٥٧٧

which, although it has its advantages for the Egyptian regime by broadening its political options, it also leaves the regime more vulnerable to challenges from outside. Applying some of the conclusions from the recent work of Sidney Tar- row on social movements, it is the emergence of just such "political op- portunities" precipitated by the fragmentation of central political power and au- thority at the centre which provides openings and rationales for violent political action. As Mitchell has written in his magisterial study of the muslim Brotherhood in Egypt, it was the disintegrating legitimacy of the political order in the 1940s and 1950s which resulted in the emergence of disdain for law and order and allowed the Brothers, along with a variety of other more secularly- minded opposition movements to accept a rationale for violence. It is this same sense of a breakdown in the legitimacy and viability of the contemporary polit- ical order in many modern Middle East states which provides perhaps the most underlying explanation for the adoption of more violent tactics by the numer- ous small militant Islamist groups that have emerged in the region in the last thirty years. Conclusion Hence, one can speak of a breakdown of institutions and norms in the Is- lamic Middle East at a variety of levels. The traditional centres of religious power and authority have begun to see their legitimacy challenged by a variety of new and varied Islamic networks; this has contributed to a parallel process whereby Islamic norms and doctrines have been interpreted in increasingly het- erogenous ways; and, finally, all of these has been underpinned by the broaden decline of the institutional strength of many of the political systems in the re- gion over the last twenty years. As Eickelaman and Piscatori note, all this has made "the rules of the game" more uncertain, unpredictable, and complex. What does this say about the future of violence done in the name of Islam in the Middle East? Let me sketch out two possibilities. The first is that the trend towards the fragmentation of institutions at a va- riety of levels will continue. Tarrow, who described the increase in violence and intolerance in the 1990s as constituting "a truly alarming trend", has argued that the increased momentum of globalization, symbolized by the weak- ening of the nation-state, the rise of integralist identities, and the diffusion of resources and reportoires for collective action around the world, may be lead- ing to the emergence of a permanent and violent "movement society" where competition for authority continually outpaces its consolidation. This in turn could lead to the reemergence of social systems which Islam and the state had previously tried to transcend such as those based upon tribe and clan. In the - 41-
ص ٥٧٧

النص مستخرج آليًّا من صور الكتاب، وقد يقع فيه خطأ.